Archive for the ‘Architecture’ Category

Ollantaytambo–Part 2

Saturday, December 12th, 2009

When the first-time visitor arrives at the base of the Ollantaytambo terraces, the structures which capture the eye are not on Cerro Bandolista; they are across the valley on Cerro Pinkuylluna.

Inca Storehouses on Cerro Pinkuylluna

Inca Storehouses on Cerro Pinkuylluna

Perched on the steep slopes of the hillside, these buildings were the Inca’s personal storehouses for the produce of his estate. 

Cerro Pinkuylluna as seen from Cerro Bandolista with the village of Ollantaytambo in between

Cerro Pinkuylluna as seen from Cerro Bandolista with the village of Ollantaytambo in between

The hillside is littered with the ruins of these storehouses, many of them in seemingly inaccessible locations.

Storehouse Ruins, Ollantaytambo

The most visible ruins are of three identical, but separate buildings.  Each had six tall windows on the downhill side, ten on the uphill side, and a doorway and a window in each gable end.  The rear section of each floor was raised, and there were covered drains or ventilation channels carved into the raised sections.

Protzen conducted some experiments on airflow using a scale model of these buildings in a wind tunnel.  He found that the closeness of the buildings with  their high-pitched roofs created negative pressure zones between the roofs and at the back of the uphill building making the buildings quite aerodynamic.  Ventilation even improved when the buildings were filled.

For details, see Jean-Pierre Protzen, Inca Architecture and Construction at Ollantaytambo, Oxford University Press, 1993.

Pachacuti’s Country Estate at Pisaq

Tuesday, December 1st, 2009

The prevailing theory seems to be that Pachacuti had Pisac (and Ollantaytambo) built after he defeated the Cuyos (and Tambos) in the Vilcanota (or Sacred) Valley.  They were his private estates, designed to both protect the valley from attack and to provide food and other resources necessary to support his family and descendants. (MacQuarrie, p. 439)

Pisac Terraces

Pisac is huge.  The ruins here are unique in that there are four distinct building areas: P’isaqa, Qanchiracay, Intihuatana, and Q’allaqasa for the elite, agricultural, religious, and military inhabitants of the complex.

Pisac map

I like the following view because it gives the viewer an idea of what the terraces looked like before and after restoration following about 400 years of non-use.Pisac Terraces

Look carefully at the slopes in the background.  It looks as if the terraces extended almost to the peak.  Given all the easily accessible good farmland in the valley, the amount of  land cultivated on the mountainsides during the time of the Incas would appear to be unnecessary unless there were a whole lot of people living here. 

Looking up the hillside from Intihuatana

Not all of the terraces were for farming.  More than 3,000 burial places stud the hillside.

Ransacked burial sites at Pisaq

Ransacked burial sites at Pisaq

And here’s a view from across the valley.

Pisac terraces as seen from across the valley

Each of the “villages” has its own character with the religious sector having the finest architecture and the Intihuatana or Sun Temple having the best of the best.

Pisaq religious sector

Pisaq religious sector

The Intihuatana and other temples
The Intihuatana and other temples

Like the Intihuatana in other locales, it is the building with the curved walls encasing a natural stone outcrop.

Intihuatana or Sun Temple

Intihuatana or Sun Temple

Also note the crude stone building to the right of the Intihuatana in the middle image.  It seems very out of place, but if there is a theory about its purpose and location, I haven’t found it yet.
Rough stone building in religious sector

Rough stone building in religious sector

Compare the workmanship to these buildings.

Temple at Pisaq

The Q’allaqasa or military citadel sits strategically above the confluence,

Q'allaqasa or military sector at Pisac
Q’allaqasa or military sector at Pisac

while the elite lived lower down on the hillside at Pisaqa.

Q'allaqasa or military district of Pisac

Pisaqa

 The peons had the crudest building works, at least as reconstructed.

A rebuilt structure at Qanchiracay

A rebuilt structure at Qanchiracay

Qanchiracay

Qanchiracay

Given the reconstruction and restoration of all but the best walls that have withstood the tests of time, it is hard to know where the reality of the 16th century has been usurped by the imagination of the 20th.  For example, look closely at the steps in the following image.  Rarely did any of the thousands of steps on the Inca Trail look this even or of such uniform height.  Obviously, some changes have made made for visitor safety, but once one begins to question, one doesn’t know where to stop. 

Was this really what it looked like around 1500?

Was this really what it looked like around 1500?

This dilemma on the part of both the caretaker and the visitor is not unique to Incan ruins.  I’ve encountered it time and time again in the American Southwest where the National Park Service (and other custodians of American Indian ruins) struggle to make places like the Cliff Palace at Mesa Verde National Park both safe and true to the past when starting with not much more than a pile of rocks and no written records.

Cliff Palace, Mesa Verde National Park, Colorado

Cliff Palace, Mesa Verde National Park, Colorado

A Little Moorish Influence

Tuesday, November 24th, 2009

Lima is known for its Moorish-style balconies enclosed by intricately carved wooden panels.  Cuzco has lots of balconies, and some of them even have fairly intricately carved wooden panels.  But, overall, the Moorish influence in Cuzco is pretty minimal.

More on Inca Walls

Sunday, November 22nd, 2009

Even though all the Incan temples and palaces in Cuzco were destroyed, there are remnants of Inca masonry to be found in the city, in places other than Saqsaywaman and Qoricancha which I’ve already discussed.  The following walls are all within a few blocks of my hotel.  Some are essentially original, some have some restoration, and some are just bits incorporated into a more modern building.

Inca Wall in Cuzco

 

Inca Wall in Cusco

 

An Inca Wall incorporated into a more modern building

The polygonal block masonry in the first two photographs is similar to that used in Saqsaywaman, just on a different scale.  Generally, this style was used for solid structures, such as terraces and canals.  The rectangular blocks laid in even courses was a style generally used in freestanding walls, as seen at Qoricancha, or interiors.

Here are several other examples from outside the city.  While the exact purpose of Tambomachay is unknown, it is known as “The Baths of the Incas” because of its series of aqueducts, canals and waterfalls.

Tambomachay

Tambomachay

Wall at Ollantaytambo

Wall at Ollantaytambo

At Ollantaytambo, which I’ll talk about in another post, there is a wall unlike any other Inca-built wall I saw.

Wall at Ollantaytambo

Wall at Ollantaytambo

It may not be obvious, but these stones are very tall, way taller than my 5 1/2′.  Huge polygonal stones were used in the walls of Saqsaywaman, but these are rectangular.  Moreover, the narrow vertical courses are truly unique.

Qoricancha, Temple of the Sun in Cusco

Sunday, November 22nd, 2009

Qoricancha was the premier temple of the Inka.  Begun around 1200 AD, Pachacuti (1438-1471) did a major remodel, adding gold plates to the walls and floors, life-size gold and silver statues of the gods to their individual sanctuaries,  and a golden garden to a  courtyard.  A large golden sun was the focal point of worship to the Inti (sun).

The Spanish stripped it bare, melted the precious metals to create ingots for shipment back to Spain, destroyed much of the building, and erected a church and convent atop the site.  The Dominican Convento de Santo Domingo was in turn partially destroyed by earthquakes in 1650 and 1950.  During the last reconstruction some of the Inca walls exposed by the collapse of their Spanish coverings were left exposed. 

The Inca were much better at constructing buildings to withstand earthquakes, so even without mortar much of the foundations date from the 13th century.

The Spanish entryway

The Spanish entryway

Note the mixture of construction styles, and how much more refined the Inca’s was.

Inca foundations

Inca foundations

Here’s a broader view of the complex.

The Convento de Santo Domingo atop the Incan foundations

The Convento de Santo Domingo atop the Incan foundations

 For some interesting photos of the 1981 reconstruction, see the Billie Jean Isbell Andean Collection at Cornell University Library.  Among the images is the following construction drawing of what the complex looked like.  Note the curved wall in the upper left corresponding to the wall shown in one of the photos above.

Qoricancha drawing

Qoricancha drawing

According to one guide book, the building with the curved wall on its west end was the Temple of the Sun.  It was over 260 feet long, 66 feet wide and 23 feet tall.  It was razed to build the church. 

Church of Santo Domingo

Church of Santo Domingo

Inside there is a model which doesn’t quite match the drawing. 

Model of Qoricancha in Cusco

Model of Qoricancha in Cusco

On the other hand, it’s the walls of the Temple of the Moon, Temple of Venus and the Stars, and the Temple of Lightning that were exposed by the 1950 quake.

The walls of Coricancha inside the cloister of Santo Domingo

The walls of Coricancha inside the cloister of Santo Domingo

The workmanship of these walls is amazing.  Note the even courses and the smoothness of the stones.  The sun god deserved the best, and got it.  As to why Inca walls have withstood earthquakes, there are several contributing factors: the walls are thicker at the base, the size of the stones decreases towards the top of the wall, and all doorways and niches are trapezoidal in shape.

Qoricancha wall

Qoricancha wall

All entrance ways have a unique double trapezoidal design.

Temple Entrance

Temple Entrance

Whereas, interior doorways are not niched.

Interior doorway

Interior doorway

As to how the Inca polished the stones, it still remains a mystery.  At least there was no consensus in 1997 when PBS aired Secrets of Lost Empires:Inca on NOVA.

 

Baroque or Renaissance?

Wednesday, November 18th, 2009

I’m no architectural expert, so having found varied opinions on the web as to whether Cusco’s Cathedral is Baroque or Renaissance, I leave it to you to decide. 

Cusco Cathedral

Cathedral Basilica of Our Lady of the Assumption, Cusco

 

Gold-covered Altar in Cusco Cathedral

Gold-covered Altar in Cusco Cathedral

There are also various declarations of when it was started, but Kelly Donahue-Wallace gives 1560 in her book on the Art and Architecture of Viceregal Latin America, 1521-1821.   Although heavily damaged in the 1650 earthquake,  it was finally completed in 1654.  The elaborate facade was designed as it neared completion in 1649.

The first clergy to arrive in Peru with Pizarro were Dominicans.  Cusco’s first church was completed in 1539–El Triunfo.

 

El Triunfo

El Triunfo. The roof-line niche was curiously empty during my visit. Presumably, its contents were off being restored or copied.

In the 1539, Franciscans began arriving to proselytize among the native population.  Then the Brothers of Mercy sent their missionaries.  The Jesuits’ didn’t arrive until 1568, and their original church was destroyed by the 1650 earthquake.  Its replacement–La Compañía de Jesús–was built in a style to rival the cathedral. 
La Compañía de Jesús

La Compañía de Jesús

 One of the reasons it took almost one hundred years to complete the cathedral was its size.  In the following photograph, it is the building with the multi-mounded roof.   The church with the dome is La Compañía.

Cusco Cathedral from Above

Cusco Cathedral from Above

 There are, of course, many other far-less-elaborate churches in Cusco.

San Blas

Church on Cusco Hillside

Cusco church

Qosqo, the Inka Center of the Universe

Friday, November 13th, 2009

According to Charles C. Mann, “In 1491 the Inka ruled the greatest empire on earth.  Bigger than Ming Dynasty China, bigger than Ivan the Great’s expanding Russia, bigger than Songhay in the Sahel or powerful Great Zimbabwe in the West Africa tablelands, bigger than the cresting Ottoman Empire, bigger than the Triple Alliance (as the Aztec empire is more precisely known), bigger by far than any European state, the Inka dominion extended over a staggering thirty-two degrees of latitude–as if a single power held sway from St. Petersburg to Cairo.” (1491, p. 64-5)

The Inka governed his empire from Qosqo where the first great Inka Pachakuti had created a 625 feet by 550 feet plaza carpeted with white sand and surrounded on three sides by stone palaces and temples veneered with gold plates.  This plaza was not only the center of the empire, it was the center of the universe.  Its magnificence was first diminished when the Inka Atawallpa had the gold stripped from its facades to help pay for his release from Pizarro (which didn’t happen).  Then, when the Catholic Spanish moved in, they felt obliged to replace the heathen temples with churches and the palaces with mansions of their own design.

Thus, today it’s hard to imagine what this city looked like in its heyday.  There is no monumental structure like the Parthenon in Athens or Coliseum in Rome to help visualize what this city looked like in its full glory.

Plaza de Armas, Cusco

Plaza de Armas, Cusco

The main plaza is much like one found in any European city.  People congregate, children chase the pigeons, and the annoying hawkers pester you ad infinitum.  Then again, I think maybe the peddlers are worse.  They try to turn a polite “No thank you” into a personal offense, laying on the guilt by the basketful.

Plaza de Armas, Cusco

Plaza de Armas, Cusco

 Buildings on the plaza exhibit their European roots with lots of balconies and arcades.

Balconies overlooking the Plaza de Armas in Cusco

 

More balconies on the Plaza de Armas in Cusco

But, I have to say that, in my opinion, not only does Cusco’s Plaza de Armas fail to provide any sense of Inka civilization, it’s pretty ho-hum in comparison to the Plaza de Armas in Arequipa in numerous aspects, including landscape design, people-watching, surrounding architecture, and just a general sense of vibrancy.

Plaza de Armas in Arequipa

Plaza de Armas in Arequipa

Everything is Made of Reeds

Wednesday, November 11th, 2009

One of the most popular excursions from Puno is to the Uros floating islands in Lake Titicaca.  The day began rather inauspiciously for a boat ride on the world’s highest (12,500′) navigable lake–dull, dreary, and chilly. 

Motoring Through the Reeds of Lake Titicaca

Motoring Through the Reeds of Lake Titicaca

The Uros people have been living on their man-made totora reed islands since the time of the Colla.  Over the centuries they have perfected their ability to fashion reeds into just about anything they need, from a place to build their homes to their homes, tools, clothes, and transportation.  In the past, fishing was their primary means of support.  Since reeds decompose over time, they must constantly replace the reeds or start again.

The islands vary in size from just a few households to small villages. 

Uros island

 

Uros floating island

Uros floating island

Each boat tour operator has one or more villages that it works with to provide a Living Tourism experience.  The difference between the Uros and the villagers of Atuncolla is that the Uros have been at it much longer.  Now tourism is their primary means of earning a living, which has its good and bad aspects. 

One or two villagers stand watch on the tall platforms to signal the arrival of their tour boat.  Everyone then gathers to greet their visitors.

Getting Ready to Greet Visitors

Visitors are escorted singly or in small groups to one of the homes where we sit on a rolled up reed mat which when unrolled provides a sleeping surface.  The owner explains how they peel the reeds so they can eat the inner core and how they use the reeds to build  and maintain their islands and homes.  In the home I visited, there was a small wooden shelf with a tiny TV/radio as well as a single halogen ceiling bulb.   They were powered by a single solar roof panel provided by the government during Fujimori’s presidency.  Until then, there was no electricity on the islands.

An Uros' Tortora Home

Some of the brightly covered clothes hanging on the walls are used to dress up their visitors.  Ignore me and check out the solar panel and how the building is constructed.

An Uros' Tortora House with Fujimori-provided solar panel

In the following photo, you can see how they bundle the reeds for drying.  Walking across the reeds is similar to walking on a firm waterbed.

Reeds stacked for drying

The homes are used mainly for sleeping.  Most work takes place outdoors or in the open shed.  Food is cooked on outdoor “stoves.”

An Outdoor Stove on an Uros Island

 

The Uros also use their reed-weaving capabilities to create products for tourists to buy.  One of the little mobiles came home with me to be used as a Christmas tree ornament.

Uros crafts for sale on a floating island

When everyone had finished their shopping, we boarded a reed boat that was rowed over to a neighboring island.  As we pulled away from the dock, the villagers lined up again to sing us a farewell song.

Uros Waving and Singing Good-bye

Sillustani–An Ancient Peruvian Burial Ground

Tuesday, November 10th, 2009
Leandro put us ashore below the chullpas of Sillustani.
Aboard "Ship" on Lago Umayo

Aboard "Ship" on Lago Umayo

From the stone quay, we hiked up to the plateau.

At over 12,000', it was a breath-taking climb! At over 12,000′, it was a breath-taking climb!

Sillustani is known for its variety of funerary structures built from adobe, uncut stones, and finely-cut stone dating from both pre-Inca and Inca times.  Groups of structures are scattered over the landscape.

A Group of Pre-Inca Chulpas at Sillustani

A Group of Pre-Inca Chulpas at Sillustani

Here are a couple of close-ups of the pre-Inca chullpas.  Since many of the structure had been desecrated by grave robbers, it wasn’t clear to me just how much restoration work had been done on them, and if there truly was as much variation in style and construction as these photos might indicate.  However, all were built of stone and mortar,

Two variations of pre-Inca chulpas

Two variations of pre-Inca chulpas

 

The stonework is different on this one.

The stonework is different on this one.

whereas those built after the Inca conquered the area used no mortar.  Their stones were shaped to fit together, and even without mortar, some had withstood tremors and destructive vandalism. 

 

The Lizard Chullpa on Sillustani

The Lizard Chullpa on Sillustani

Scholars believe the local elites learned how to work the stone from their Inca conquerors and modified their customary style to be more in tune with their conquerors.

 

The Lizard

The Lizard

 Note how the stones are rectangularly faced and how the structure has a greater diameter at the top than at the bottom.  All the shaping and polishing was accomplished without stone tools.  The lizard chullpa is 39 feet tall with a diameter of 16 feet; its walls are five feet thick.

 These finely-cut and shaped structures encircled an inner tomb that was not much different than the pre-Inca tombs.  Supposedly, it was shaped like a woman’s uterus, and the mummified corpse was placed inside the tomb in the fetal position.
Backside of the Lizard Chulpa on Sillustani

Backside of the Lizard Chullpa on Sillustani

It wasn’t clear why this chullpa had been partially reconstructed.

 Another Inca Chullpa at Sillustani

This one appears unfinished as the protuberances were used to support the ramps and scaffolding needed to raise the stones and assemble the structure.  Once the structure was completed, they were removed and the stone faces polished.

An Unfinished Chullpa on Sillustani

In the following example, you can see the tomb entrance, which typically faced east and was only one to two feet high.
 
An Eastward-facing Chullpa Entrance

Chullpas were much like our family mausoleums.  Family members were added when they died.

Puno

Monday, November 9th, 2009

I spent three nights in Puno where I stayed in the Puno Plaza Hotel, right on the main square–the Plaza de Armas.  My days were so busy I never had the time or energy to roam very far, so my views of Puno were limited to those from my hotel balcony.  Sound dull?  Not if you’re an inveterate people-watcher like I am.

Let’s start with the truly dull stuff.  Puno is a city near Peru’s southern border with Bolivia.  It’s located at an elevation of 12,421 feet and has about 100,000 residents.  The city’s cathedral dates from the 17th century.  I was never around when it was open to visitors, so I don’t know what it looked like on the inside.

Puno's cathedral

Puno's cathedral

Now to an unexciting photograph that’s worth some time examining, starting with the tall white building.

The street at the other end of Plaza de Armas, opposite the cathedral

The street at the other end of Plaza de Armas, opposite the cathedral

Since earthquakes are a fact of life in the area, there are few tall buildings.  Few new buildings exhibit any signs of exterior style; most are akin the shop building in the foreground–boxy and utilitarian.  Also, note its location in the middle of the block.  It is unclear whether it is attached to another building or not.  Lots of non-commercial buildings have only small windows, if any, facing the street, and they usually have some sort of ironwork over them.  I also gathered that property taxes are a function of a building’s state of completion; there are lots of unfinished buildings with rebar sticking up from the flat roof.  Maybe they intend to add another floor; maybe not.  All of these factors make this building rather unique.

The swan

The swan

Next, note the absence of any vehicle on the street.  It’s 4:30 p.m. on a weekday!  I didn’t notice this fact at the time; it was a portent of things to come.

On the other hand, there is what looks to be a woman walking a bicycle.  She really has a sort of backwards tricycle.  Lots and lots of bicycles and tricycles have been converted to shops on wheels by entrepreneurs of various sorts.  This woman sells ice cream cones.

Ice cream vendor in Puno

Ice cream vendor in Puno

Curiously, at least for me who worked in downtown DC, there aren’t many people walking around given the hour.  There were more when I went out later to dinner and walked along this block.  The street converts to pedestrian-only at the next intersection, and numerous restaurants and shops can be found in this pedestrian zone.

And now, the people.  What do you think was happening on this park bench? 

Three People on a Bench @ Time 1

Three People on a Bench @ Time 1

Just a minute later,

Three people on a bench @ Time 2

Three people on a bench @ Time 2

In this first photo, there is no eye contact between the man and the young woman.  A minute later, they are both smiling.

Close-up of man at time 2

 

The woman at time 2

 

What did he say to her?  And what about the older woman whom the younger one is sitting close to?  She seems so resolute at ignoring what is happening beside her.  In another age, I would have thought she might be the duenna.