Archive for May, 2010

Punakha Drubchen: Day 3–The Reenactment, Part 1

Monday, May 31st, 2010

Starting around 9:30 a.m. on the third and last day of the drubchen, the pazap squads left their camps for the dzong–one group at a time.

Leaving camp

There seemed to be no particular order or formation in the way they arrived or ascended the staircase.  Here’s squad one–

Pazaps arriving at dzong

Arriving at dzong

Up the staircase

 

and squad two–

Another group arrives

Starts up staircase

On the staircase

I was quite surprised at the informality of the arrival process; it was all so un-military. 

Then we had a one to 1 1/2-hour wait while the pazaps participated in a ceremony in the dzong courtyard.  Since it was an either/or choice between the dzong courtyard or the exterior of the dzong because of the staircase, we had elected to stay outside.

In contrast to the pazaps entrance into the dzong, their exit was highly dramatic–and prolonged.  The pazaps exited in pairs or triplets yelling and brandishing their swords as they descended to the staircase landing.  Other pazaps added to the noise of the simulated battlefield by setting off firecrackers.

 

Pazap on staircase landing

Here they performed a sword dance with more yelling.

Pazap yelling and brandishing sword

Pazap yelling and brandishing sword

Back at the top of the staircase, something was going on with the monks.

Monks at top of staircase

Monks at top of staircase

Here’s another pazap who had to perform the dance while holding a standard.

Another Pazap with standard brandishing sword

Another Pazap with standard brandishing sword

I couldn’t usually see the second or third pazap, but in this case I caught two in my photo.

Two Pazaps

The last member of the squad to descend was the general.

A General starting down staircase

 

But he didn’t dance.  He just walked down and mounted his horse.  From my vantage point, I couldn’t tell who was twirling the standard.

Twirling ribbons

Here’s the next horse waiting for his general.

A Horse waiting for his General

The generals exited in four directions, so I had one chance to grab a photo.

Galloping away

With 136 pazaps and 8 generals, we knew it was going to take a while for everyone to do their dance and exit the dzong.  So, we moved our location to get a good spot for the finale.

Punakha Drubchen: Day 2–The Pazaps

Sunday, May 30th, 2010

The Zhabdrung’s “army” consisted of eight local militia.  At the drubchen there are just 17 pazaps or warriors in each of the squads, for a total of 136, and each squad has a general.  Only men belonging to the Wang Tshochengye – the eight great clans or geogs situated within the boundaries of the Thimphu and Punakha regions-can play the role of a pazap.

Pazaps

Pazaps

 

Pazap General

Pazap General

 

Pazap Footwear

Pazap Footwear

The pazaps gather before the drumchoe begins; each squad setting up its own camp.

Pazag Encampment outside dzong

Pazap Encampment outside dzong

Each squad also brings a horse.
Pazaps horses grazing outside dzongPazaps’ horses grazing outside dzong

 

After the pazaps ascend the dzong’s entrance stairway, they perform a dance.
Pazaps dancing

Pazaps dancing

Inside the dzong they create a circle inside a square and perform a ceremonial dance or procession around the courtyard.  Sporadically the warriors set off fireworks simulating the firing of guns into the air.
Pazaps Dancing in Dzong Courtyard

Pazaps Dancing in Dzong Courtyard

Upon the completion of this dance, they all sat down in two sets of facing rows.  A monk then read a long document which I assume had something to do with their obligations, a mixture of rules and goals that included a pep talk since at various times the warriors would whoop it up.  At the end, the pazaps pledged an oath of allegiance.

Pazaps listening to their charge

Pazaps listening to their charge

Then it was time to inspect the troops.  Among the dignitaries doing the inspection were the local member of parliament, district manager, and other high ranking officials.

Inspecting the Troops

Inspecting the Troops

When the formal ceremonies were complete, a prolonged photo op began.  Each group got its chance to be photographed with the dignitaries, starting with the generals.

Generals and Dignitaries at Photo Op

Generals and Dignitaries at Photo Op

Birding in Punakha

Saturday, May 29th, 2010

When we left the drubchen at mid-day, we walked along the Mo Chhu and then drove northeast along the Pho Chhu searching for birds.  Being mid-day, we really didn’t see many, but there were some Great Cormorants, Common Shelducks, and Ruddy Shelducks.

Common Shelduck

Common Shelduck

 

Ruddy Shelduck

Ruddy Shelduck

The next day when we left the dzong, we drove north along the Mo Chhu where we also saw mallards, a Crested Kingfisher, a White-throated Kingfisher (a beautiful bird), a Crested Serpent Eagle, and some sort of kestrel.

Crested Kingfisher

Crested Kingfisher

White throated Kingfisher

White throated Kingfisher

 

Crested Serpent Eagle

Crested Serpent Eagle

We got fairly close to a River Lapwing, but my pictures are terrible

River Lapwing at Punakha
River Lapwing at Punakha

so here’s someone else’s.

River Lapwing
River Lapwing

But the best find of the two days–and for the entire trip–was a White-bellied Heron. 

White bellied Heron
White bellied Heron

The White-bellied Heron is one of the 50 rarest birds in the world.  According to this news story there were only 30 in Bhutan in 2008.  We had gone in search of the bird at a known rookery, but hadn’t seen any birds, much less one of the rare ones.  Then, on the way back to the dzong, there was one in the middle of the Pho Chhu not far from the dzong.

White-Bellied Heron
White-Bellied Heron

We also some langurs, but I didn’t get any photos until later in my trip.  I did take some photos of a pet monkey on a pole in someone’s front yard. 

Pet Monkey on a box Pet Monkey on a box

It was wrapped in a blanket or shawl sitting on a wooden box that reminded me of a wood duck box minus a front side.

Pet Monkey with Blanket
Pet Monkey with Blanket

Driving along the Mo Chhu we went as far as a picnic area near a waterfall.

Waterfalls in Upper Punakha Valley

Waterfalls in Upper Punakha Valley

Across the river, up on a hill, is the 100-foot tall Khamsum Yuelley Namgyal Chorten, which after eight years of construction was consecrated in 1999.

Khamsum Yuelley Namgyal Chorten

Khamsum Yuelley Namgyal Chorten

Back at my hotel, I finally got a good view of a pair of Long-tailed Minivets (but not good enought for pictures like these).

Long tailed Minivet (male)

Long tailed Minivet (male)

Long-tailed Minivet (female)

Long-tailed Minivet (female)

Punakha Drubchen: Day 1 Masked Dances

Friday, May 28th, 2010

The masked dances (or cham) began with what I interpreted as four stags.  It may have been the Shacham or Shazam Cham, but these stags had ankle-length red robes not the knee-length yellow ones I found reference to on the internet.

Stag Dancer at Punakha Drubchen

Mask dances have their roots in 8th century Tibetan Buddhism.  Many of the dances seen today were choreographed in the 17th century or earlier.  Supposedly all of the dancers are monks or male members of the Royal Academy of Performing Arts.

Stag Dancer at Punakha Drubchen

Stag Dancers at Punakha Drubchen

 

Stag Dancers at Punakha Drubchen

Stag Dancers at Punakha Drubchen

 

Stag Dancer at Punakha Drubchen

Stag Costume's Collar Detail

Stag Mask

 

After this dance, a group of young people performed a dance.  I gathered from Pelden that the introduction of non-mask dances (and women) is something new.

Contemporary Dance at Punakha Domchoe

Next came a dance that began with at least three different figures which I interpreted as a garuda (bjachung), wild boar (phabi), and a raven.

What is this horned creature?

Note the object in his left hand below–and the wedding ring.  Do monk’s wear wedding rings?

 

Close-up of Horned Creature

This dancer has something different in his hand.

A Pig

 

Close-up of Pig 

Perhaps the figure on the right is a raven.  It doesn’t have horns. Pig and a Raven perhaps

 

A Raven?

Ravens?

Then came a group in red rather than blue robes.

Guru? 

Mask detail

This one might be a “terrifying deity”.

Terrifying Deity? 

Another terrifying deity

Maybe a monkey?

Monkey maybe

I have no clue

 

Wild boars?

Wild boar?

 

Wild boar & terrifying deity?

Perhaps the judge (ox)?

Ox?

The ox?

This may be the snake.

Crocodile?

These have multiple faces

Multiple personality

 

Multiple personality

 

The musicians stood along the side.

Musicians

Note the men behind the musicians–the pazaps.  We’ll get to them in another post.

Musicians and pazaps

Twirling demons

There obviously was a story behind the dance, but the cast of characters does not seem to match up with any on this list.  Nor do all of the masks appear on this list.  But my guess is this was the Raksha Marcham or Mangcham (Judgement of the Dead).  It was forty minutes from the point at which the masked dancers began after the young women finished until my last photo of the dance when we left for lunch.  If this was the Raksha Mangcham, it continued on for a couple more hours.

Punakha Drubchen, February 21-23, 2010: Day 1

Thursday, May 27th, 2010

I timed my visit to Punakha to coincide with the three-day Punakha Dromchoe.  The Punakha Domchhoe is attended by thousands of people from all over the kingdom, as well as a few tourist. (I mean that literally, not facetiously.)  The three-day drubchen is part of a  two-week celebration that includes a tsechu (which I didn’t attend).  In 2010, the Domchoe was February 21-23.

I’ve hunted around on the internet for details about what I saw, but the best I found was a schedule from some unknown year and a story on RAOnline.  Unsurprisingly, not much jives with what I saw.

We arrived at the dzong around 9 a.m. where we were greeted by monks offering blessings in the form of neck cords and some sort of awful-tasting pellets.  Soon thereafter the grand procession began.

Administrators

Men are required to wear a kabney (silk scarf) which indicates their rank when they are inside an official building like a dzong.  For commoners, it’s a plain white, fringed kabney.  Gups or administrators of Bhutan’s 201 gewogs wear a kabney with a red stripe.  Additional stripes and different colors indicate different types of office holders.  If I remember correctly, Pelden introduced me to a man with a green stripe as one of the new members of parliament, but I won’t swear to that.

Elected Officials

Trumpeters

Note the traditional footwear.

Drummers

After the procession, there was a wait.    I used the time to take pictures of my surroundings including a student group that congregated near where I sat. 

Punakha Dzong decked out for Drubchen

Punakha Dzong decked out for Drubchen

It wasn’t clear why this group of students were dressed in their school uniforms.  Perhaps they had come some distance to attend the festival or they would have some role later on.  They certainly had a prime location.

Waiting Their Turn?

Students Awaiting Their Turn?

After about twenty minutes the first masked dancer appeared–but you’ll have to wait until tomorrow.

The Rangjung Kharsapani

Wednesday, May 26th, 2010

On the 9th day of the first month of the Bhutanese year, almost everyone who lives within walking distance of the Punakha dzong arrives in his best gho or her best  kira to witness a sleight of hand involving the Rangjung Kharsapani. 

Je Khenpo throwing oranges into Mo Chhu

Je Khenpo throwing oranges into Mo Chhu

In 1639 Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal tricked a Tibetan army by secreting the relic in his sleeve and throwing a subsitute into the river.  With this sleight of hand he saved his throne, allowing the country he had created–Bhutan–a chance to survive.

In 1616 the Zhabdrung fled his hereditary throne in Tibet when the most powerful lord in Tibet decided to recognize someone else as the reincarnation of the Gyalwang Drukchen.  The Zhabdrung took the Rangjung Kharsapani with him and established a new power base in the Thimphu valley, from which he managed to repel a Tibetan invasion in 1618.  He eventually gained control over most of what is now western Bhutan, even though the Tibetans continued their periodic invasions.  Things weren’t going too well for the Bhutanese in 1639 against the Tibetans when the Zhabdrung used his bag of tricks rather than arms to entice his attackers to leave.

First, knowing where the Tibetans had set up their lookouts, he had his smaller army march out of the dzong in a seemingly endless stream, as the men circled the dzong, re-entered through a hidden back door, and emerged again.  As a consequence, the Tibetans thought themselves outnumbered instead of vice versa.  Thus, when the Zhabdrung emerged one night at the end of a solemn procession that proceeded to the river where he threw the substitute relic into the current, the Tibetans were no longer interested in dying for a lost cause.  Instead, they packed up and left.

So what is the Rangjung Kharsapani?  Rangjung means ‘self-created.’  This self-created image of Avalokiteshvara, or Chenrezig in Tibetan,  is said to have emerged from one of the vertebra in the cremated remains of Tsangpa Gyare, the founder of the Drukpa school of Tibetan Buddhism.  Chenresig is an enlightened being who is a manifestation of all Buddhas’ compassion, the Buddha of Compassion.   This particular statue has one face and two arms with lotus stalks in the left hand and the right hand in a position of protection.

Bhutanese believe: “Just having a glimpse or seeing the Rangjoen Kharsapani is equivalent of seeing the Avalokiteshwara in personal/real. If one prays with utmost faith and devotion, it is believed to bring forth many merits/good fortune for oneself and other, and purify all the wrong deeds and dispel of all the bad obscuration we have accumulated in the past lives. Moreover it clears away all the malevolent spirits and protects us from outer, inner and the most inner obstacles of this lifetime and brings forth longevity, free of all diseases, good fortune etc. And fulfills our dreams and attains the heavenly paradise and finally nirvana.”

Given the religious and historic importance of this figure, you can imagine the tumult created when it was stolen in 2000.  Unfortunately, I’ve been unable to find any details on the Internet.  Somehow it was recovered, but it did not appear in public again until 2007.
Nor have I been able to find historical details about the Punakha Drubchen (or Domchhoe or Dromchoe), the annual reenactment.  Certainly it has existed for more than 50 years, as the Queen Mother Ashi Dorji Wangmo Wangchuck recounts her childhood visits to the festival in her book Treasures of the Thunder Dragon: A Portrait of Bhutan.   But, has it really been occurring annually since the Zhabdrung’s time as some sources imply?
You’ll have to wait for my next post for details about the three-day drubchen.

Palace of Great Happiness, Punakha Dzong–Part 3

Tuesday, May 25th, 2010

Now it’s time to head inside the walls of this huge (590 by 236 feet) structure, but first we must pass through a small gate in a low wall that creates a small, grassy entrance plaza.

Entrance Gateway to Punakha Dzong

Entrance Gateway to Punakha Dzong

From this plaza, it’s a long way up the wooden entrance steps.  Designed in the 17th century so that they could be pulled up in the event of an attack, they’re not the easiest steps to climb.

Main Entrance to Punakha Dzong

Main Entrance to Punakha Dzong

Just inside there are a number of paintings, including one of the Four Harmonious Friends.  For an explanation of the symbolism, see  Thuenpa Puen Zhi.

Four Friends

Four Harmonious Friends

This dzong has three instead of the usual two courtyards or docheys.  To give you an overall view of the dzong, here’s a photo of the model I saw in Thimphu.  The largest building on the left is the utse; the open space to its left is the administrative courtyard.

Model of Punakha Dzong in National Library at Thimphu

Model of Punakha Dzong in National Library at Thimphu

The utse is massive;

Utse of Punakha Dzong

Utse of Punakha Dzong

the carving in the window bays spectacular.

Upper Story Windows of Utse

Upper Story Windows of Utse

The decorations on the roof corners are not gargoyles in the sense that they carry water from the roof.

Roof Decoration
Roof Decoration
In the first, administrative courtyard stands a bodhi tree and a large chorten.  (The dzong’s entrance is behind the chorten in the following photo.)
Bodhi Tree and Chorten
Bodhi Tree and Chorten

The second courtyard, which is surrounded by monk’s quarters, is fairly small since a temple was built there in 1978 (or 1983, depending on the source) to the Tantric deity Cakrasamvara.  

Temple in Second Courtyard of Punakha Dzong

Temple in Second Courtyard of Punakha Dzong

In the third is a large assembly hall or kuenrey (kunre) for the monks, as this is the winter home of His Holiness the Je Khenpo and 250 monks.

Kuenre or Large Assembly Hall

Kuenre or Large Assembly Hall

Also located in the third courtyard is a temple containing the remains of the Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal, the man who unified Bhutan and built the dzongs across Bhutan.  Only the king and the Je Khenpo can enter the room where the remains are kept.

Temple in Punakha Dzong

Temple in Punakha Dzong

The following photo provides a close-up of the ground floor windows.

Close-up of Window Painting

Close-up of Window Painting

Also hidden away in the utse is Bhutan’s most treasured possession–the Rangjung Kharsapani, which I’ll discuss in my next post.

A Gallery of Bridges

Monday, May 24th, 2010

Just for something different, I’ve put together a gallery of bridge photos since my last post brought to mind my visits to several notable bridges.

Palace of Great Happiness, Punakha Dzong–Part 2 (The Bazam)

Sunday, May 23rd, 2010

Did you notice the lovely cantilevered bridge across the Mo in my last post?

Punakha Dzong on the Mo Chhu

Punakha Dzong on the Mo Chhu

The original cantilever bridge (bazam) over the Mo Chhu was destroyed by a GLOF in 1958, which also widened the channel to be spanned from about 105 feet to 165 feet.  It was replaced by a steel cable bridge, presumably with more character than these two nearby bridges across the Pho.

Steel Cable Pedestrian Bridge over the Pho Chhu

Steel Cable Pedestrian Bridge over the Pho Chhu

 

Steel Cable Bridge near Punakha

Steel Cable Bridge near Punakha

 

But, obviously, any steel bridge would not have been in keeping with the 350-year-old wood and stucco dzong.  The problem was the new channel width.  No one knew how to span such a wide channel with a wooden cantilevered bridge.  In 2000 Pro Bhutan–Germany, an organization which had planned, financed, and built Punakha’s hospital and medical training facility, was asked by the prime minister to build a new wooden, cantilevered bridge.  It, in turn, solicited the help of Walt + Galmarini AG, a Swiss engineering firm that specializes in bridge building.

The Bazam to Punakha Dzong

The Bazam to Punakha Dzong

The result is a spectacular bridge that uses hidden steel elements “to stabilise the high bridge arch and to prevent it from twisting or falling sideward.”  The new bridge was completed in May, 2008.  At 55m, it is the longest unsupported span in the traditional cantilever architecture in the world.  Be sure to follow the link above to see construction photos.

 

The Bazam over the Mo Chhu The Bazam over the Mo Chhu

 

Also note the location of the dredges in the above photo viz a viz their location in my last post.  The above photo was taken Sunday morning when the yellow dredge was stuck. 

Palace of Great Happiness, Punakha Dzong–Part 1

Saturday, May 22nd, 2010
Punakha Dzong from Northwest with Mo Chhu in foreground

Punakha Dzong from Northwest with Mo Chhu in foreground

Built by Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal in 1637-38, Punakha’s dzong is the second oldest and second largest of Bhutan’s dzongs.  It’s official name “Pungtang Dechen Photrang Dzong” means palace of great happiness or bliss.  Until the capital was moved to Thimphu, this was the administrative center of Bhutan; the clergy still winter here. 

 

Punakha Dzong with Mo Chhu in foreground

Punakha Dzong with Mo Chhu in foreground

The dzong is beautifully situated at the confluence of the Pho (Father) Chhu and Mo (Mother) Chhu.

Punakha Dzong from Pho Chhu Punakha Dzong from Pho Chhu

 Over the centuries there have been additions and renovations, some necessitated the 1897 earthquake and numerous fires, the last of which was in 1986.  In addition to the 1986 fire, many of the wooden structures within the walls had been allowed to deteriorate over the years.  Therefore, in the late 1980s the king ordered a complete reconstruction.  After a significant amount of work had been done, the foundation was determined to be inadequate, and much of the work had to be redone after the foundation was strengthened.  Then, in 1994, a massive flash flood occurred on the Pho, and additional restoration work was added to the already long list of projects, along with flood control.  If my interpretation of this website about the dzong’s reconstruction is correct, work was not completed until 2004.

 
Punakha Dzong--Southeast CornerPunakha Dzong–Southeast Corner

 

Work continues on flood control though, and even more is planned.   The problem is GLOFs—Glacial Lake Outburst Floods—at the headwaters of the Pho.  According to Pelden, the Pho once flowed as close to the dzong as the Mo still does.  Plans call for the confluence to be moved 900 feet downstream.

Dredging the Mo Chhu

Dredging the Mo Chhu

When we arrived at Punakha Dzong on Sunday morning, the blue dredger was working to free the yellow one, which was stuck  in the middle of the river.  The above picture was taken mid-day on Monday.  The very first picture on Tuesday afternoon.  In my three days at the dzong, the driver of the blue machine always seemed to be working, even though most locals were attending the festival inside the dzong.  It’s hard to see in these pictures, but in that time, a lot of stones and gravel were moved.